01 -
Take a medium microwave-safe bowl and add the peanut butter along with maple syrup. Microwave for about 40-60 seconds until it’s softened enough to mix. Stir it well until the two combine smoothly and look uniform.
02 -
Slowly mix the oat flour into the warm peanut butter blend. Stir thoroughly, even though it’ll feel quite heavy. If needed, switch to using a stand mixer for less effort. Dough should be thick but pliable. Add a bit more peanut butter or maple syrup by the teaspoon if it’s too crumbly. Optionally, stir in some pumpkin puree (around 1/4-1/3 cup) to make it softer.
03 -
Use cupcake liners to prep a standard muffin pan or opt for silicone versions to avoid sticking. If you want bite-sized treats, go for mini muffin tins instead. Without liners, it'll be hard to take them out of a regular pan after chilling.
04 -
Spoon the thick peanut butter dough into the prepped muffin cups, making sure to divide it evenly between them. Press the mix down with your fingers so it forms a smooth, firm base with just a small dip in the center for the chocolate layer.
05 -
Place chocolate chips in another microwave-safe bowl. If you'd like, add a touch of coconut oil. Microwave in short bursts of 30 seconds, stirring after each round, until the chocolate melts fully and becomes glossy.
06 -
Spread the melted chocolate over the peanut butter base in the cups. Smooth the chocolate’s surface with the back of a spoon. While the chocolate’s still soft, sprinkle on extras like flaky salt, sprinkles, or mini chocolate chips if you want.
07 -
Pop the filled trays into the fridge for 2-3 hours, or until they’re completely set. Once firm, carefully remove them from the pans. To keep them fresh, store in a sealed container in the fridge and eat within 5 days.