Pin it
I stumbled on this recipe during last winter and now it's what I cook when I want friends to leave impressed without me sweating all day in the kitchen. The name fits perfectly - everyone wants the recipe after their first taste.
Key Components and Shopping Advice
- Bone-in Chicken: Go for pieces with skin on for extra flavor. The bones really boost your broth's taste.
- Sun-dried Tomatoes: Pick ones packed in oil for richer flavor. You'll need that oil for cooking the chicken.
- Cheese Tortellini: The fresh ones from the refrigerated section cook faster and stay firmer than dry versions.
- Heavy Cream: Don't skimp with low-fat options. You need full-fat for smoothness and to stop breaking.
- Havarti Cheese: This cheese melts beautifully and has a gentle flavor that works with everything else.
- Fresh Spinach: Look for crisp, dark leaves with no soggy parts. They'll bring color and goodness to your soup.
Crafting Your Soul-Warming Soup
- Step 1: Get the Chicken Golden
- Start by warming the oil from those sun-dried tomatoes until it's hot. Sprinkle chicken with salt and pepper. Drop it skin-down into the hot pan and let it get nice and brown. This step packs your soup with amazing taste.
- Step 2: Build Your Flavor Foundation
- Toss chopped onions into the same pan, letting them soak up all those tasty bits from the chicken. When they're golden, throw in your garlic and tomato paste. Cook until the paste darkens and sticks a bit to the pan - that's where the good stuff happens.
- Step 3: Make Your Awesome Broth
- Splash in some broth, scraping up all those stuck bits. Dump everything into your slow cooker with the rest of your broth and seasonings. This stacking of flavors makes your soup taste like it took all day to make.
Pin it
Seeing my family's excitement when I bring this soup to the table makes all the prep totally worth it. Those swirls of cream and cheese running through the broth remind me of the soups I've had at fancy Italian places.
Balancing Creaminess and Heat
Be careful when you're mixing in the cream and cheese - too much heat will make them separate. Take the pot off high heat before slowly stirring them in, waiting for each bit to melt before adding more.
Prep Work Shortcuts
This soup is perfect for company since you can do lots of the work beforehand. Finish through step 5, then stick it in the fridge. Just add the tortellini and final touches right before you want to eat.
Keeping Flavors in Check
Though it's creamy and rich, the lemon juice and spinach add brightness that keeps things from getting too heavy. I sometimes toss in extra veggies like mushrooms or colorful peppers for more variety.
Pin it
This soup has become what everyone asks me to make for gatherings, mixing comfort food vibes with fancy restaurant feels in every bite. Using the slow cooker makes it doable on busy days but still tastes like you worked all day on it.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Can I swap in boneless chicken?
- Sure thing, go with boneless chicken breasts but cook them about an hour less since they get tender quicker than bone-in pieces.
- → Is browning the chicken really worth it?
- The browning step adds tons of flavor to your soup. Those crispy bits from the pan bottom give the broth amazing depth.
- → Will this soup freeze well?
- You can freeze the base but leave out the tortellini and cream. Just add these when you're warming it up so the pasta doesn't turn mushy.
- → What cheese works instead of Havarti?
- Try using mozzarella or provolone if you can't find Havarti. They melt nicely and have a similar mild taste.
- → Can I cook this on my stove?
- Definitely. Just let it bubble gently for about an hour until your chicken feels tender. Then toss in the tortellini and finish up as the recipe says.