Pin it
Pistachio tiramisu takes the familiar Italian dessert and cranks up the indulgence with a deep nutty hit you won't forget. Smooth pistachio mascarpone and coffee-soaked ladyfingers stack up for an amazing mix of flavors and textures. You get all the classiness without the fuss—just layer and chill, that's it!
I came across this take on tiramisu while checking out some trendy Italian spots and instantly decided to try it myself. Now, we always want the pistachio one at our house for celebrations. The lovely pale green really pops on the table and folks are always wowed by the way it looks before even digging in.
Unbeatable Ingredients
- Chopped pistachios: Give the top a nice crunch and make it look fancy.
- Mascarpone cheese: The creamy heart of the whole thing, making every bite rich and smooth.
- Egg yolks: Add that soft, thick texture when properly whisked with sugar.
- Vanilla extract: Brings a cozy note that makes all the flavors pop.
- Pistachio cream: Packs a powerful nutty kick that sets this apart from any other tiramisu.
- Heavy cream: Fluffs things up so the filling stays light, not dense.
- Strong brewed coffee: Soaks the biscuits and gives a bold background flavor.
- Ladyfinger biscuits: Soak up that coffee and keep the whole dessert together.
Step-by-Step Build
- Assembly:
- Grab a square dish around 9 inches across. Dunk each ladyfinger quickly in the coffee, just a second per side, and line the bottom. Spread half the creamy pistachio mix over them so it covers everything. Add another layer of coffee-dipped biscuits, then the rest of the pistachio cream. Use a handy spatula to smooth out the top.
- Whipping the Cream:
- Get your coldest bowl and pour in super cold heavy cream. Beat it until you see soft little peaks that keep their shape. Use a spatula to gently fold this fluffy cream into the pistachio-mascarpone mix, scooping from bottom to top until everything's even.
- Pistachio Cream Mix:
- Put egg yolks and sugar in a bowl set over a pot with simmering water, but not touching. Whisk for five minutes until it looks pale and thicker. This step cooks the eggs safely. Take off the heat and whisk another minute so it cools a bit. Stir in mascarpone, pistachio cream, vanilla, and almond extract until it turns a smooth green with no lumps.
- Making the Coffee:
- Brew up some strong coffee, even stronger than you'd usually have. Cool it in a shallow bowl to room temp, then stir in rum or coffee liqueur if you want to. Letting it cool means your biscuits won't get mushy, and the optional booze gives an extra depth to the taste.
Pin it
The first time I put this together, I couldn't believe how perfectly pistachio and coffee flavors worked side by side. My crew loves the difference between the creamy center and the nutty crunch on top. Seriously, get the best pistachio cream you can find—it takes the flavor over the top.
Real Serving Tips
Show off those pretty layers by serving from the fridge after it's had a little time out—about 15 minutes at room temp is perfect. Wait to sprinkle your nuts on top until the last minute so they stay extra crunchy. For neat pieces, use a sharp knife dipped in warm water each time you slice. Plates chilled in the fridge and tiny forks make eating each layer even better.
Fun Ways to Switch It Up
You can mess with this dessert a bunch of ways! Try stirring some instant espresso powder into the mascarpone cream for a bigger coffee hit. If you've got a sweet tooth, melt in some white chocolate to the cream. For a non-alcoholic version, swap the booze for almond milk mixed with instant coffee. Summer? Add a handful of berries for a fresh kick. Want to get really fancy for a party? Dust on some edible gold with the pistachios.
Easy Storage Hacks
This dessert actually gets better after sitting in the fridge awhile. Cover it up with plastic so it's airtight and chill for at least four hours—overnight is even better. Leftovers are solid for four days in the fridge, sealed up tight. For long term, freeze single pieces (skip the pistachios), then pop them in freezer bags. They'll last three months. Let defrost in the fridge overnight and add fresh pistachios before serving.
Pin it
This pistachio tiramisu nails that simple, elegant vibe with a little twist. I love watching friends try it for the first time—the pistachio with coffee always gets surprised smiles. Making it is honestly super relaxing for me, from folding that fluffy cream to dunking the biscuits just right. Plus, that flash of green beside the light cookies looks so fancy but still feels homey, which is what it's all about in my kitchen.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Where can I find pistachio paste for this tiramisu?
- Look in Italian or fancy food stores, especially in their baking aisles, or just order pistachio paste online. If you're stuck, toss roasted pistachios, a little sugar, and some neutral oil in a food processor and blend till smooth. There you go.
- → Can I make this Pistachio Tiramisu without alcohol?
- For sure! Just skip the rum if you want to keep it booze-free. You’ll still get all those bold coffee and pistachio flavors.
- → How far in advance can I make this dessert?
- It actually gets tastier if you make it ahead. You can throw it together 1–2 days before serving and keep it chilled. Letting it sit helps the layers get even better.
- → Are there safety concerns with using raw eggs in tiramisu?
- Classic tiramisu uses uncooked eggs, but you can swap for pasteurized ones or gently heat the yolks and sugar over simmering water until they hit 160°F (71°C) if you’re worried. That way, you’ve got safe custard and peace of mind.
- → How long will Pistachio Tiramisu keep in the refrigerator?
- Seal it tight and pop in the fridge—it’ll last up to 4 days. Honestly, after a day or so, the flavors get even better and richer.
- → Can I freeze leftover Pistachio Tiramisu?
- Freeze it for up to 3 months, tightly wrapped first in plastic then foil. Let it thaw overnight in your fridge before eating. The texture might change a bit but the taste holds up.