Chocolate Protein Pudding

Just toss these basics in your blender and end up with an extra creamy, chocolatey snack that’ll kill your cravings while being loaded with 19 grams of protein for each serving. You only need a few minutes to whip up this rich, smooth treat, and you’ll still be hitting those nutrition marks. Unlike those store-bought options with too much sugar and weird stuff you can’t pronounce, this homemade version is full of ingredients you’ll actually feel good about having again and again.

I came up with this when I was deep in a tough training streak and needed quick ways to get more protein—especially when my sweet tooth just wouldn’t quit. After my first go, I was shocked how much it felt like regular chocolate pudding but with that bonus nutrition hit. Now I make it almost every week, mostly after sweaty workouts when I want chocolate more than anything but still really need the protein.

Luscious Simple Ingredients

• Whey protein powder: Makes the whole thing thicker while ramping up the protein.
• Allulose: Gives clean, subtle sweetness without the blood sugar spikes.
• Vanilla extract: Adds a richer chocolate taste and a warm smell.
• Cottage cheese: Provides the ultra-creamy texture and tons of protein.
• Unsweetened cocoa powder: Brings deep chocolate flavor and natural antioxidants without extra sugar.

Simple Steps

Serving Up:

Eat it straight from the blender with fruit, whipped cream, or nuts. You can pop it in the fridge for a firmer spoonful.

Dial In That Taste:

Give it a try and add more cocoa or allulose for your perfect flavor.

Master That Texture:

Toss in a splash of almond milk or a bit more protein powder if you need to tweak the consistency.

Easy Blending:

Pour everything in, blasting on low first, then crank it up for the smoothest batch.

Quick Setup:

Have your ingredients laid out and ready to roll before you blend to keep things moving fast.

Told my nutritionist about this one and she was shocked you could get this much protein while making something so tasty for chocolate fans. Now she swears by it and suggests it whenever her clients want something sweet after a sweat session.

Pin it

Fun Twists

Try adding mint extract for that cool peppermint vibe, stir in some espresso powder to make it mocha, or drop in orange zest to brighten things up with some citrus and chocolate magic.

Seasonal Spins

Top with fresh berries once summer hits, spiced apples for cozy autumn nights, peppermint pieces when it’s winter, or a little lemon zest and blackberries as soon as spring rolls in.

Extra Nutrition

Add ground flaxseed for healthy fats, a sprinkle of cinnamon to help keep blood sugar steady, some shredded coconut for a fun texture, or a scoop of Greek yogurt if you want even more protein.

Tasty Sides

Grab some almonds for a crunchy kick, toss in fresh berries for a natural sweet punch, or sip with green tea for an antioxidant boost alongside your chocolate treat.

Smart Storage

Keep it in a tight container in your fridge for up to four days. Lay a bit of plastic wrap right on the surface before closing to stop it from getting that pudding skin.

Pin it

If you want super smooth pudding, keep the blender running for a solid minute. That’s all it takes for a perfect spoonful every time.

Frequently Asked Questions

→ Can I use a different protein powder in this pudding?

You sure can. Swap in a different protein powder if you’d like. Vanilla casein will make it thicker. Trying plant-based proteins like pea or brown rice changes up the taste and feels a bit, but works fine. If your protein powder doesn’t have a flavor, try adding a splash of vanilla or some extra sweetener so it pops.

→ Is there a dairy-free alternative to cottage cheese for this recipe?

Don’t want dairy? Go for silken tofu (the firm kind) in the same amount. Toss in a spoonful more protein powder so the protein stays high. It comes out a little less thick, but still tasty. Or use thick coconut yogurt—but remember, that one has less protein and a bit more fat.

→ Can I use regular sugar instead of allulose?

Of course you can! Use the same amount (about two tablespoons), just know it won’t be sugar-free anymore. Other sweeteners like erythritol, monk fruit, stevia, or coconut sugar work, too. They all vary in sweetness, so taste and tweak. Even liquid ones like honey or maple syrup will do, but they make it a bit thinner.

→ Why is my pudding not smooth enough?

If it’s not silky smooth, your cottage cheese probably isn’t blended enough. Use a strong blender or food processor—give it at least a minute. Smaller curd cottage cheese gets smoother than the bigger ones. Let the cottage cheese warm up a bit before blending so it breaks down easier.

→ How can I increase the protein content even further?

Want more protein? Add another scoop of powder (go from 2 to 3 tablespoons). Swapping in Greek yogurt for some of the cottage cheese also bumps up the protein. For a bigger boost, sprinkle in some chopped nuts or plop a spoonful of Greek yogurt on top when you serve it.

→ Can this pudding be used as a healthy frosting?

Absolutely! Cut the cottage cheese back to about 3/4 cup and bump the protein powder up to 3 tablespoons for a thicker, frost-worthy mix. Chill well (a couple hours is best). Spread it on brownies, healthy muffins, or dunk fruit. It’ll firm up more in the fridge, great for piping too.