Maple Butter Sandwich

Featured in: Desserts for Every Sweet Craving

This maple butter breakfast sandwich will make your mornings feel special. A quick whisk of maple syrup into softened butter transforms this sandwich into a sweet and savory surprise. Toasty English muffins hold crispy sausage, folded eggs, and melty cheddar, all topped with maple butter. Simple for hectic weekdays yet fancy enough for relaxed brunches. The magic lies in the maple-infused butter balancing savory and sweet flavors. You’ll love this morning upgrade.
A woman with blonde hair and a white shirt smiles at the camera.
Updated on Fri, 09 May 2025 15:06:25 GMT
A delicious breakfast sandwich featuring egg and cheese. Pin it
A delicious breakfast sandwich featuring egg and cheese. | tastefullyrecipe.com

Filling sausage discs coupled with airy eggs and gooey cheese make the perfect morning boost when tucked into toasted English muffin pieces coated with maple-infused butter. This breakfast combo packs tons of taste without fancy methods or hard-to-find stuff, making it great for days when you want solid food before going outside. The maple butter turns a basic sandwich into something you'll remember, creating a nice sweet-meets-savory mix that keeps hunger away for hours.

I found the maple butter trick during a freezing cold January when we were getting ready for a family ski weekend. The light sweetness went so well with the meaty sausage that everyone asked for these sandwiches again the next day. Now we always make them before any outdoor activity that needs lots of energy.

Winning Ingredients

  • English muffins: Try to find ones with lots of holes to soak up the maple butter.
  • Breakfast sausage patties: Get good quality ones, maybe from your neighborhood meat shop.
  • Eggs from nearby farms: The deep yellow yolks pack more good stuff.
  • Old sharp cheddar cheese: It gets all melty without breaking apart.
  • Real maple syrup: Don't use the fake breakfast syrup if you want true flavor.
  • Unsalted butter: Let it sit out until soft for the right maple butter texture.

Building Your Sandwich

Getting Muffins Ready:
Break muffins apart with a fork instead of cutting them to make more rough spots. Toast until they're golden with slightly crunchy edges but still a bit soft inside.
Making Maple Butter:
Combine two tablespoons of room-temp unsalted butter with one tablespoon real maple syrup. Mix until they're totally blended and the same color throughout.
Cooking The Sausage:
Warm up an iron pan on medium. Put sausage patties in and push down lightly so they cook evenly. Cook about 3 minutes each side, or until they reach 165°F inside.
Cooking Eggs Just Right:
After taking out the sausage, cook eggs in the leftover fat. Break the yolks so they won't run when you're eating. Add a pinch of salt and pepper. Cook until whites aren't clear but yolks are still a bit soft, about 2 minutes.
Adding Cheese:
Put a big slice of sharp cheddar on the hot egg during the last minute. Cover the pan briefly to make steam so the cheese gets all melty without overcooking the egg.
Putting It Together:
Spread lots of maple butter on both toasted muffin pieces. Put the sausage on the bottom half, then add the egg with melted cheese. Top with the other muffin half and push down gently.
Wrapping It Up:
For taking with you, wrap sandwiches in paper, fold the ends and tie with kitchen string. This stops drips and makes it easy to unwrap while you're eating.

My grandma showed me what real maple syrup was all about when I visited her Vermont farm as a kid. She taught me how to tell fake syrup from the real stuff, and explained how maple farmers tap trees carefully so they stay healthy. Now I always use genuine maple syrup for breakfast as my small way of honoring her lessons about using good ingredients even for basic meals.

Complete Nutrition

This sandwich gives you full nutrition through smart ingredient choices. The protein in eggs and sausage offers important amino acids, while the English muffin gives you complex carbs for lasting energy. The small amount of dairy from cheese and butter provides calcium and vitamin D without too much fat, making this a well-rounded breakfast choice.

A breakfast sandwich with eggs and cheese. Pin it
A breakfast sandwich with eggs and cheese. | tastefullyrecipe.com

Quick Morning Meal

This recipe gets the balance just right between good nutrition and easy prep. Basic ingredients you normally keep around let you put it together fast without special shopping trips. The whole process from grabbing stuff from your fridge to having a wrapped sandwich takes under fifteen minutes.

Taste Combinations

The mix of sweet maple, hearty sausage, soft egg, and tangy cheddar creates a perfectly matched bite. The maple butter brings extra flavor, cutting through the richness of meat and cheese, turning this basic sandwich into something that tastes much fancier.

Easy To Carry

Made for eating while on the move, this sandwich stays together thanks to how it's built. Breaking the yolk before cooking stops messy drips, while wrapping it in paper means less cleanup when you're eating it.

What To Serve With It

Enjoy this sandwich with some fresh fruit for extra fiber and vitamins. A cup of tart yogurt adds good bacteria and different texture. When you have more time in the morning, herb-seasoned crispy potatoes make a great side dish.

Different Ways To Make It

  • Healthier Version: Use turkey or chicken sausage instead of pork.
  • Less Cholesterol: Skip the yolks and just use egg whites.
  • Different Cheeses: Try gouda or havarti for new flavors.
  • Gluten-Free: Get gluten-free English muffins instead.

Storing Leftovers

Wrap made sandwiches in paper and keep in the fridge up to three days. For longer storage, wrap in paper first, then foil, and write the date on it before freezing. Heat up refrigerated sandwiches in a toaster oven at 350°F for six minutes or frozen ones for twelve minutes.

A breakfast sandwich with eggs, cheese and bacon. Pin it
A breakfast sandwich with eggs, cheese and bacon. | tastefullyrecipe.com

After trying loads of breakfast options over the years, this sandwich always hits the spot without being too complicated. Whether you need fuel for outdoor activities or just want to start your workday right, this sandwich gives you serious nourishment with comforting flavors that work every time.

Frequently Asked Questions

→ Can I mix the maple butter ahead?
Sure! You can whip it up a week in advance and pop it in the fridge. Just let it soften before spreading.
→ What if I don’t eat pork sausage?
Try turkey sausage as a leaner swap. Or go for plant-based patties if you’d like a veggie option.
→ Is there a gluten-free option?
Totally! Just swap out the muffins with gluten-free ones or any other bread you like.
→ Can I prep these sandwiches to freeze?
Yes! Build the sandwich but skip the maple butter. Wrap in foil, freeze, and reheat them at 350°F for 15-20 minutes. Add fresh maple butter when ready to eat.
→ What’s the best cheese for it?
Cheddar’s a classic choice, but try American, Swiss, or even pepper jack for a twist.

Maple Butter Sandwich

Enjoy a perfect combo of juicy sausage, soft-cooked eggs, gooey cheddar, and lightly sweetened maple butter spread on toasted English muffins.

Prep Time
5 Minutes
Cook Time
15 Minutes
Total Time
20 Minutes
By: Patricia


Difficulty: Easy

Cuisine: American

Yield: 4 Servings (4 sandwiches for breakfast)

Dietary: ~

Ingredients

→ Basic Stuff for Sandwiches

01 4 English muffins split in half
02 4 big eggs
03 4 slices of cheddar cheese
04 8 oz of pork sausage

→ Butter with Maple Flavor

05 1 tablespoon pure maple syrup
06 4 tablespoons softened salted butter

Instructions

Step 01

Divide the pork sausage into 4 patties of roughly the same size. Heat a large skillet on medium-high with a spritz of non-stick spray, and cook each side for 3-4 minutes until they're browned and crisp around the edge. Move the finished patties onto a plate lined with paper towels to drain off extra grease.

Step 02

Tip out the oil from the skillet, then put it back on a medium flame. Whisk eggs together in a bowl with a touch of salt and pepper. Pour them into the pan and let them sit until the top just starts to set but is still a bit shiny. Gently fold the eggs over. Take the pan off the heat and let the eggs finish on their own with the skillet's warmth.

Step 03

Whip your softened butter in a bowl until it’s smooth, then stir the maple syrup in until it’s evenly mixed. At the same time, pop the English muffins in a toaster until nicely golden.

Step 04

Smear about 1 tablespoon of maple butter on each muffin half. Start layering with a folded egg on one side, followed by a sausage patty. Drop a slice of cheese on top and pop it in the microwave for 20-30 seconds to melt the cheese. Place the other muffin half on top. Use the remaining ingredients to make all four. Eat while warm and gooey!

Notes

  1. Josh's top pick for breakfast! The maple butter adds a perfect touch.
  2. Adapted from Two Peas and Their Pod.

Tools You'll Need

  • Non-stick pan, good size
  • Bowl for mixing
  • A whisk or fork
  • A toaster
  • Microwave oven

Allergy Information

Please check ingredients for potential allergens and consult a health professional if in doubt.
  • Milk involved (from butter and cheese)
  • Egg allergy alert
  • Gluten present (from muffins)

Nutrition Facts (Per Serving)

It is important to consider this information as approximate and not to use it as definitive health advice.
  • Calories: 485
  • Total Fat: 32 g
  • Total Carbohydrate: 28 g
  • Protein: 22 g